OpenBSC

openbsc@lists.osmocom.org

13 participants
4246 discussions

Adding doxygen style comments to header files
by Alexander 'lynxis' Couzens 05 Mar '25

05 Mar '25

Hi, it came up again in gerrit again. Currently the osmocom style states doxygen style comments should be done in the .c file. Doxygen are those comments: /*! a brief description of the function * \param something Some description of the use * \return 0 if ... */ Doxygen takes those comments and generates a html documentation of the code. I would like to change it to have those in the headers files instead (when the function in included in a header file). When using the doxygen comments only for doyxen, for sure, there isn't a difference between having it in .c or in .h files. But when using IDEs or language servers, they usually only parses headers files and the .c files of the current active project (e.g. osmo-sgsn), but not the .c files of other projects (libosmocore). On the downside I only see the problem of increasing the size of header files, but I don't see an issue in here. Any thoughts? Best, lynxis

5 6

certificate bypass in osmoepdg
by subhajit.chatterjee 18 Feb '25

18 Feb '25

Hi, I was going through the features of osmoepdg solution and thought to ask few questions regarding the implementations. 1. In most of deployment tunnel authentication is bypassed. So, even if UE send CERTREQ, it is getting ignored at ePDG. ePDG also doesn't send anything to UE. Do you have any idea of how to implement that in strongswan or have you explored that earlier? I saw that in 3gpp 33.402 and RFC 5996, certificate things are optional. However, I know that strongswan authentication is tightly coupled, so just trying understand if you have already bypass it by doing any changes in strongswan or atleast know how it should be done. 2. There are many error and status codes written in ePDG standard 24.302 clause 8. Have you mapped all EPC core error to corresponding IKEv2 error or status codes? Thanks & Regards Subhajit Chatterjee New Delhi

2 4

BSC graceful shutdown
by Sipos Csaba 17 Feb '25

17 Feb '25

Dear List, With Domi we are working on some improvements on the Nokia Site E1 based BTS types, mainly focusing on the OML side. Among many things (see the upcoming patches), one thing we would like to add is to lock all TRX-es at BSC shutdown. The OML command structures we already have, but when we added this part to the shutdown_om() function we noticed that only the first TRX receives the command, the rest does not. When we looked at the E1 capture even more surprise: the capture file lacks the OML command of the first TRX which we locked successfully (cross checked with BTS manager). Enabling LAPD debug also indicates that there is no graceful shutdown of the lapd links as well, which is my suspicion for the failing locking of TRXes except of TRX1: the connection is just cut before the last couple TRX lock commands can pass and we got just lucky with the first one timing-wise. I think Harald or Pau mentioned a new FSM which is likely not implemented/backported for the Nokia BTS variant. The question is: does the new FSM does a graceful shutdown or maybe handles it better than the current code? I looked at the rbs2000 as an example also but I don't see that the shutdown part is handled any different/ better. At this point I have no idea if this is the expected behavior, a bug or a missing feature? The fact we are missing an OML message in the PCAP which clearly passed the E1 line kind of indicates a bug at least there. I am not sure but likely other BTS types might also benefit from a graceful shutdown (eg. at least lock all TRXes). The Nokia variants clearly do: without the TRXes locked, at the next BSC startup all the unlocked TRXes inadvertently start random RSL bootstraps, even in the middle of a site reset, filling the log with random errors. Please let me know if there is any example code we should look at, and/or what your opinion is about this subject in general. Regards, Csaba

2 1

EFR and AMR voice calls
by Sipos Csaba 07 Feb '25

07 Feb '25

Dear list, FR calls between mobile phones are working fine, but when I change the codec-list to "codec-list fr2 fr1 fr3" or "codec-list fr3 fr1 fr2", I am getting a Remote Transcoder Failure: lchan(0-0-1-TCH_F-0)[0x630d01c78b80]{ESTABLISHED}: (type=TCH_F) CONNECTION FAIL (cause=Remote Transcoder Failure [ 28 ]) In the BSC config: codec-support fr efr amr codec-list fr2 fr1 fr3 In the MSC config: mncc-int default-codec tch-f fr default-codec tch-h hr Both the phones and the BTS is FR/EFR/AMR capable. I am fairly sure with Osmo-NITB at least EFR was working with these phones and BTS some years ago. If needed, I can provide a pcap. If someone has an idea, please let me know. Regards, Csaba

3 5

The Importance of Freight Forwarding Service for My Manufacturing Business
by olivianaylor322＠gmail.com 03 Feb '25

03 Feb '25

As the owner of a manufacturing business, I’ve come to realize how crucial efficient logistics are. When I first started exporting products overseas, handling shipping on my own was a constant struggle. After partnering with a freight forwarding service https://www.cfipak.com/ , everything changed. They handle the complexities of shipping, customs, and delivery, allowing me to focus on production and growth. With their expertise, my shipments are now timely and cost-effective. If you're in manufacturing or any business with global reach, investing in a freight forwarding service will save you time and stress, helping your business thrive.

1 0

The Importance of Freight Forwarding Service for My Manufacturing Business
by olivianaylor322＠gmail.com 03 Feb '25

03 Feb '25

As the owner of a manufacturing business, I’ve come to realize how crucial efficient logistics are. When I first started exporting products overseas, handling shipping on my own was a constant struggle. After partnering with a <a href="https://www.cfipak.com/">freight forwarding service</a>, everything changed. They handle the complexities of shipping, customs, and delivery, allowing me to focus on production and growth. With their expertise, my shipments are now timely and cost-effective. If you're in manufacturing or any business with global reach, investing in a freight forwarding service will save you time and stress, helping your business thrive.

1 0

Access to Nokia Flexi BTS / Flexi Multiradio equipment
by Sipos Csaba 02 Feb '25

02 Feb '25

Dear list, I wonder if anyone has access to Nokia Flexi BTS or Flexi EDGE / Multiradio equipment and can provide access to it for the purpose of adopting Osmo-BSC to support for these units? In case someone has a unit like this (with whatever radio), please let me know. Regards, Csaba

1 0

Is It Worth It to Pay Someone to Take My Online CompTIA Exam?
by olivianaylor322＠gmail.com 31 Jan '25

31 Jan '25

I’ve been struggling with my CompTIA exam prep and honestly, it's been hard to manage everything. The idea of asking someone to take my online CompTIA exam for me https://www.theresearchguardian.com/take-my-comptia-exam-for-me/ seemed a bit extreme at first, but after seeing how many students do it, I’m starting to consider it seriously. If anyone has tried this service, I’d love to hear your thoughts. Was it worth the investment? How reliable were the test takers? I just want to make sure I'm making the right choice.

1 0

Separate RSL bootstrap to LAPD and BCCH+SACCH
by Sipos Csaba 20 Jan '25

20 Jan '25

Dear list, At the moment setting up the RSL lapd link and start its bootstrap (BCCH info and SACCH filling) is done in one go (as much as I can see). The issue with this is for the Nokia Site family: per spec. we should let the RSL lapd link to be initiated by the BTS and once that lapd link is up, the BTS sends a BTS_STATE_CHANGED message with "TRX, enabled" object id and object current state, and only after this we should start sending the BCCH info and SACCH filling (the "actual" bootstrap of the RSL). For this to work, we need the Object Identity and Object Current State attributes (which is a WIP atm), but somehow it should be possible to separate the RSL bootstrap to RSL lapd only and RSL bcch info + sacch filling. I am unaware if the above separation is possible with the current codebase, but if someone can shed some light on this, that would be appreciated. Adding the Object Identity and Object Current State will also allow us to detect the actual state changes of various BTS objects (mostly the TRX), and we can also use the BTS_CHA_ADM_STATE to actually lock/unlock TRXes, so we dont need to fake the 12.21 state anymore. Regards, Csaba

3 4

Looking for BS11 mounting plates
by Alexander Huemer 05 Jan '25

05 Jan '25

Hi! I am in possession of a pair of Siemens BS11 mounting plates and am looking for a second pair. A photo of the plates is attached. Since - I believe - most people who play with such basestations do not mount them to a wall or pole, my hope is that some unused ones are floating around somewhere. Thanks, -Alex^Wblackbit

2 4

Jump to page:

2026

2025

2024

2023

2022

2021

2020

2019

2018

2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

OpenBSC