I've tried matching the sample rates, it doesn't seem to make much difference. I
just didn't happen to have saved the text from one of those.
I've also tried the -r option, but I didn't hear anything and I wasn't sure it
was sending "raw" audio and not I/Q signals. It acted better, aside from that:
the progress meter in Play was responding constantly like it was getting more audio and
the file sizes were more like what I'd expect. With the bursting, I get 16k every
minute, which is way too short.
I wrote some C to import one of the files and export as ascii, then make a Gnuplot file to
plot it. There's a sample at:
http://ab1jx.webs.com/toys/dongle/wfm2_dat3.gif (The X axis labels are data point
numbers.)
It looks like audio, but I see something in the output about a 6 millisecond sample
buffer. That's possibly how much sound I get, and this sample is from the local NPR
station so I don't know what they were doing at that instant, music or voice. I also
haven't tried plotting I/Q output so I don't know what that looks like.
Yes, my sound works and playing a wav file with Play (Sox) works. I normally work at 8000
samples/second mono. No Linux sound to get in the way here (OpenBSD). From reading, it
doesn't make sense to have the RF sampling rate the same as the audio sampling rate (I
think) but that's what it defaults to.
OK, it helps to be reassured that somebody actually uses this and has it working.
I'll mess with sampling rates and raw mode. Some real documentation for these
programs would be a help.
Alan
-----
Radio Astronomy - the ultimate DX
----- Original Message -----
From: Adam Nielsen <a.nielsen(a)shikadi.net>
To: Alan Corey <alancorey(a)yahoo.com>
Cc: "osmocom-sdr(a)lists.osmocom.org" <osmocom-sdr(a)lists.osmocom.org>
Sent: Monday, December 31, 2012 1:28 AM
Subject: Re: Trying to use rtl_fm, etc
With rtl_fm, I get a tiny burst of audio about
once a minute.
A fresh run:
freebie# rtl_fm -N -f 162550000 - | play -t raw -r 32k -e signed-integer -b
16
-c 1 -V 4 -
Just FYI, you can see here that:
Output at 24000 Hz.
However you have told 'play' to play the audio at a sampling rate of
32kHz, even though the audio data is only arriving at 24kHz. So you will get
stuttering as the audio buffer keeps running out and waiting for more data to
arrive.
For me (under Linux), I get best results using the -r option to rtl_fm to set
the output audio sampling rate to 48kHz, then tell play to play at 48kHz too.
This way my system doesn't have to resample it to 48kHz before it can mix
the stream into the system-wide audio output.
Note that the -s option sets the signal bandwidth and -r sets the output audio
sampling rate. A lot of people misunderstand the purpose of the -s option,
however you shouldn't need it unless you are trying to receive data signals.
-W and -N set -s to the correct values for voice transmissions.
I would also suggest playing a .wav file with the same 'play' options
just to make sure your system can play mono audio at low sampling rates. I know
my sound card drivers won't (possibly because I am using a SPDIF connection
to an external amplifier) so I need the Linux audio system to upmix it to 48kHz
16-bit stereo or I won't hear anything.
Cheers,
Adam.