Steve Markgraf steve@steve-m.de wrote:
I don't quite see how waving the Free Software flag and distributing proprietary source from the TSM30/Locosto leaks (pretty much everything in freecalypso-sw/gsm-fw/) go together.
That source is NOT proprietary, it is *ex*-proprietary. It *was* proprietary, but not any more - it is now in the public domain.
Free Software is not just a "flag" to be waved, it is a practical reality: in *practical* terms, software that is based on ex-proprietary code that has been liberated through the exercise of Eminent Domain and subsequently developed and maintained in the manner of a free sw project gives its users all of the 4 freedoms defined by FSF.
However, I shall leave it here -- any further replies or comments or questions in this thread will *not* elicit a further reply from me. But if there is anyone else on this list who desires a usable cellphone for talking to his or her significant other like I do, please be assured that I have no plans of dropping the project; the work is progressing at a steady pace as you can see from the Mercurial commit history, and I have high hopes of some actually-usable result some time around the end of 2014.
VLR, SF
Hi Michael,
On 05.08.2014 21:50, Michael Spacefalcon wrote:
That source is NOT proprietary, it is *ex*-proprietary. It *was* proprietary, but not any more - it is now in the public domain.
Even though the circumstances under which this code now suddenly should be public domain in the US are unclear to me: There is no such thing as the public domain in most countries - including the country where the code was written in (France) and the country where the current entity holding the copyright resides in (Germany).
However, I shall leave it here -- any further replies or comments or questions in this thread will *not* elicit a further reply from me.
You are taking the easy way out...
Best Regards, Steve
However, I shall leave it here -- any further replies or comments or questions in this thread will *not* elicit a further reply from me.
How about you do us a favor, take this a step further, and stop posting here all together ?
Cheers,
Sylvain
baseband-devel@lists.osmocom.org