Hello everyone! I'm new to simtrace and I'm trying to set up a test with a Simtrace2 board connected to a RPI (which I'll call the client from now on) and a different RPI with an attached card reader (which I'll call the server).
The server runs osmo-remsim-bankd and osmo-remsim-server (installed from your debian repo). The bankd server has its configuration csv file filled with the correct reader information. The osmo-remsim-server runs on the same machine and has a mapping configured via the python api tool to map client 1 to bank 1, like so:
root@rpi-cardem-1:~# python3 /etc/osmocom/osmo-remsim-apitool -a /clients: {'clients': []} /banks: {'banks': [{'peer': 'B1', 'state': 'CONNECTED_BANKD', 'component_id': {'type_': 'remsimBankd', 'name': 'fixme-name', 'software': 'remsim-bankd', 'swVersion': '1.0.0'}, 'bankId': 1, 'numberOfSlots': 5}]} /slotmaps: {'slotmaps': [{'bank': {'bankId': 1, 'slotNr': 1}, 'client': {'clientId': 1, 'slotNr': 1}, 'state': 'ACTIVE'}]}
The client runs osmo-remsim-client-st2 like this: root@rpi-cardem-2:~# osmo-remsim-client-st2 --server-ip remsim-server --server-port 9998 --client-id 1 --client-slot 1 --usb-vendor 1d50 --usb-product 60e3 --usb-config 1 --usb-interface 0 --usb-path "1-1.4"
However, based on the logs, it tries to contact the bankd server at 127.0.0.1:9999 instead of remsim-server:9999:
DRSPRO INFO ../rspro_client_fsm.c:307 RSPRO_CLIENT(server){REESTABLISH}: Creating TCP connection to server at remsim-server:9998 DLINP NOTICE simtrace2_api.c:271 [0] <= osmo_st2_cardem_request_config(features=00000001) DLINP NOTICE input/ipa.c:141 remsim-server:9998 connection done DRSPRO NOTICE ../rspro_client_fsm.c:127 RSPRO_CLIENT(server){REESTABLISH}: RSPRO link to remsim-server:9998 UP DRSPRO INFO ../rspro_client_fsm.c:307 RSPRO_CLIENT(bankd){REESTABLISH}: Creating TCP connection to server at 127.0.0.1:9999 DRSPRO NOTICE ../rspro_client_fsm.c:127 RSPRO_CLIENT(bankd){REESTABLISH}: RSPRO link to 127.0.0.1:9999 DOWN
The bankd server listens on 0.0.0.0 on the server side: root@rpi-cardem-1:~# netstat -tpan | grep osmo | grep LISTEN tcp 0 0 0.0.0.0:9997 0.0.0.0:* LISTEN 409/osmo-remsim-ser tcp 0 0 0.0.0.0:9998 0.0.0.0:* LISTEN 409/osmo-remsim-ser tcp 0 0 0.0.0.0:9999 0.0.0.0:* LISTEN 405/osmo-remsim-ban
My question is - how is osmo-remsim-client-st2 getting the IP address of the bankd server? What did I do wrong?
I've tried a few tricks to redirect traffic from 127.0.0.1:9999 to remsim-server:9999, but so far have failed. This is what I've tried as a proxy, but the connection seems to get garbled because netcat expects LF terminated strings: nc -l 127.0.0.1 9999 | nc remsim-server 9999
Thanks for the help Cheers, Adrian
Update - I've created a better tunnel via ssh port forwarding (why did I ever bother with netcat?), to bypass the connection problem:
root@rpi-cardem-2:~# ssh -L 9999:remsim-server:9999 pi@remsim-server
Starting the client now shows other repeating messages I need to figure out: root@rpi-cardem-2:~# osmo-remsim-client-st2 --server-ip remsim-server --server-port 9998 --client-id 1 --client-slot 1 --usb-vendor 1d50 --usb-product 60e3 --usb-config 1 --usb-interface 0 --usb-path "1-1.4" DRSPRO INFO ../rspro_client_fsm.c:307 RSPRO_CLIENT(server){REESTABLISH}: Creating TCP connection to server at remsim-server:9998 DLINP NOTICE simtrace2_api.c:271 [0] <= osmo_st2_cardem_request_config(features=00000001) DLINP NOTICE input/ipa.c:141 remsim-server:9998 connection done DRSPRO NOTICE ../rspro_client_fsm.c:127 RSPRO_CLIENT(server){REESTABLISH}: RSPRO link to remsim-server:9998 UP DRSPRO INFO ../rspro_client_fsm.c:307 RSPRO_CLIENT(bankd){REESTABLISH}: Creating TCP connection to server at 127.0.0.1:9999 DLINP NOTICE input/ipa.c:141 127.0.0.1:9999 connection done DRSPRO NOTICE ../rspro_client_fsm.c:127 RSPRO_CLIENT(bankd){REESTABLISH}: RSPRO link to 127.0.0.1:9999 UP DRSPRO ERROR ../rspro_client_fsm.c:297 RSPRO_CLIENT(bankd){REESTABLISH}: Event SRVC_E_KA_TERMINATED not permitted DRSPRO INFO ../rspro_client_fsm.c:302 RSPRO_CLIENT(bankd){REESTABLISH}: Destroying existing connection to server DRSPRO INFO ../rspro_client_fsm.c:307 RSPRO_CLIENT(bankd){REESTABLISH}: Creating TCP connection to server at 127.0.0.1:9999 DLINP NOTICE input/ipa.c:141 127.0.0.1:9999 connection done DRSPRO NOTICE ../rspro_client_fsm.c:127 RSPRO_CLIENT(bankd){REESTABLISH}: RSPRO link to 127.0.0.1:9999 UP DRSPRO ERROR ../rspro_client_fsm.c:297 RSPRO_CLIENT(bankd){REESTABLISH}: Event SRVC_E_KA_TERMINATED not permitted
The bankd daemon says: Jul 08 10:27:00 rpi-cardem-1 osmo-remsim-bankd[405]: 526 DBANKDW INFO bankd_main.c:442 [003 CONN_CLIENT_MAPPED] Changing state to ACCEPTING Jul 08 10:27:00 rpi-cardem-1 osmo-remsim-bankd[405]: 522 DBANKDW INFO bankd_main.c:955 [000 ACCEPTING] Accepted connection from 127.0.0.1:57908 Jul 08 10:27:00 rpi-cardem-1 osmo-remsim-bankd[405]: 522 DBANKDW INFO bankd_main.c:442 [000 ACCEPTING] Changing state to CONN_WAIT_ID Jul 08 10:27:00 rpi-cardem-1 osmo-remsim-bankd[405]: 522 DBANKDW INFO bankd_main.c:655 [000 CONN_WAIT_ID] Rx RSPRO connectClientReq(T=0, N='rpi-cardem-2', SW='remsim-client', VER='1.0.0') Jul 08 10:27:00 rpi-cardem-1 osmo-remsim-bankd[405]: 522 DBANKDW INFO bankd_main.c:442 [000 CONN_WAIT_ID] Changing state to CONN_CLIENT Jul 08 10:27:00 rpi-cardem-1 osmo-remsim-bankd[405]: 522 DBANKDW INFO bankd_main.c:625 [000 CONN_CLIENT] slotmap found: C(1:1) -> B(1:1) Jul 08 10:27:00 rpi-cardem-1 osmo-remsim-bankd[405]: 522 DBANKDW INFO bankd_main.c:450 [000 CONN_CLIENT] Changing state to CONN_CLIENT_MAPPED (timeout=10) Jul 08 10:27:00 rpi-cardem-1 osmo-remsim-bankd[405]: 522 DBANKDW INFO bankd_pcsc.c:261 [000 CONN_CLIENT_MAPPED] Attempting to open PC/SC context Jul 08 10:27:00 rpi-cardem-1 osmo-remsim-bankd[405]: 522 DBANKDW INFO bankd_pcsc.c:264 [000 CONN_CLIENT_MAPPED] SCardEstablishContext: OK Jul 08 10:27:00 rpi-cardem-1 osmo-remsim-bankd[405]: 522 DBANKDW INFO bankd_pcsc.c:215 [000 CONN_CLIENT_MAPPED] Attempting to find card/slot using regex 'SCM Microsystems Inc. SCR 3310 [CCID Interface] (53312144266274) 00 00' Jul 08 10:27:00 rpi-cardem-1 osmo-remsim-bankd[405]: 522 DBANKDW INFO bankd_main.c:967 [000 CONN_CLIENT_MAPPED] Error -2 occurred: Cleaning up state Jul 08 10:27:00 rpi-cardem-1 osmo-remsim-bankd[405]: 522 DBANKDW INFO bankd_main.c:442 [000 CONN_CLIENT_MAPPED] Changing state to ACCEPTING
Does this mean that it doesn't find the reader? Though the name is the one reported by pcsc_scan: root@rpi-cardem-1:~# pcsc_scan | head Using reader plug'n play mechanism Scanning present readers... 0: SCM Microsystems Inc. SCR 3310 [CCID Interface] (53312144266274) 00 00
Sat Jul 8 10:30:44 2023 Reader 0: SCM Microsystems Inc. SCR 3310 [CCID Interface] (53312144266274) 00 00 Event number: 0 Card state: Card inserted, ATR: 3B 9F 96 80 1F C7 80 31 E0 73 FE 21 13 67 98 07 02 10 01 01 01 54 ATR: 3B 9F 96 80 1F C7 80 31 E0 73 FE 21 13 67 98 07 02 10 01 01 01 54
Or is this a consequence of my port forwarding attempt? Thanks!
On Sat, Jul 8, 2023 at 12:12 PM Adrian Popa adrian.popa.gh@gmail.com wrote:
Hello everyone! I'm new to simtrace and I'm trying to set up a test with a Simtrace2 board connected to a RPI (which I'll call the client from now on) and a different RPI with an attached card reader (which I'll call the server).
The server runs osmo-remsim-bankd and osmo-remsim-server (installed from your debian repo). The bankd server has its configuration csv file filled with the correct reader information. The osmo-remsim-server runs on the same machine and has a mapping configured via the python api tool to map client 1 to bank 1, like so:
root@rpi-cardem-1:~# python3 /etc/osmocom/osmo-remsim-apitool -a /clients: {'clients': []} /banks: {'banks': [{'peer': 'B1', 'state': 'CONNECTED_BANKD', 'component_id': {'type_': 'remsimBankd', 'name': 'fixme-name', 'software': 'remsim-bankd', 'swVersion': '1.0.0'}, 'bankId': 1, 'numberOfSlots': 5}]} /slotmaps: {'slotmaps': [{'bank': {'bankId': 1, 'slotNr': 1}, 'client': {'clientId': 1, 'slotNr': 1}, 'state': 'ACTIVE'}]}
The client runs osmo-remsim-client-st2 like this: root@rpi-cardem-2:~# osmo-remsim-client-st2 --server-ip remsim-server --server-port 9998 --client-id 1 --client-slot 1 --usb-vendor 1d50 --usb-product 60e3 --usb-config 1 --usb-interface 0 --usb-path "1-1.4"
However, based on the logs, it tries to contact the bankd server at 127.0.0.1:9999 instead of remsim-server:9999:
DRSPRO INFO ../rspro_client_fsm.c:307 RSPRO_CLIENT(server){REESTABLISH}: Creating TCP connection to server at remsim-server:9998 DLINP NOTICE simtrace2_api.c:271 [0] <= osmo_st2_cardem_request_config(features=00000001) DLINP NOTICE input/ipa.c:141 remsim-server:9998 connection done DRSPRO NOTICE ../rspro_client_fsm.c:127 RSPRO_CLIENT(server){REESTABLISH}: RSPRO link to remsim-server:9998 UP DRSPRO INFO ../rspro_client_fsm.c:307 RSPRO_CLIENT(bankd){REESTABLISH}: Creating TCP connection to server at 127.0.0.1:9999 DRSPRO NOTICE ../rspro_client_fsm.c:127 RSPRO_CLIENT(bankd){REESTABLISH}: RSPRO link to 127.0.0.1:9999 DOWN
The bankd server listens on 0.0.0.0 on the server side: root@rpi-cardem-1:~# netstat -tpan | grep osmo | grep LISTEN tcp 0 0 0.0.0.0:9997 0.0.0.0:* LISTEN 409/osmo-remsim-ser tcp 0 0 0.0.0.0:9998 0.0.0.0:* LISTEN 409/osmo-remsim-ser tcp 0 0 0.0.0.0:9999 0.0.0.0:* LISTEN 405/osmo-remsim-ban
My question is - how is osmo-remsim-client-st2 getting the IP address of the bankd server? What did I do wrong?
I've tried a few tricks to redirect traffic from 127.0.0.1:9999 to remsim-server:9999, but so far have failed. This is what I've tried as a proxy, but the connection seems to get garbled because netcat expects LF terminated strings: nc -l 127.0.0.1 9999 | nc remsim-server 9999
Thanks for the help Cheers, Adrian
Hi Adrian,
I think the problem might be that you connect your bankd to the server via localhost/loopback IP. This means the server stores '127.0.0.1' as the bankd IP and then passes it on to the client.
Simply tell your bankd to connect to a "real" IP address of remsim-server, this way the bankd-side source address selection will also use a "real" address and hence register that in the remsim-server instaed of 127.0.0.1
Thank you for the help. I had started osmo-remsim-bankd with -i 0.0.0.0 thinking it would listen on all interfaces. I used a fixed IP and now the client can use it. This can be considered solved
Cheers
On Tue, Jul 11, 2023 at 11:45 AM Harald Welte laforge@osmocom.org wrote:
Hi Adrian,
I think the problem might be that you connect your bankd to the server via localhost/loopback IP. This means the server stores '127.0.0.1' as the bankd IP and then passes it on to the client.
Simply tell your bankd to connect to a "real" IP address of remsim-server, this way the bankd-side source address selection will also use a "real" address and hence register that in the remsim-server instaed of 127.0.0.1
--
- Harald Welte laforge@osmocom.org https://laforge.gnumonks.org/
============================================================================ "Privacy in residential applications is a desirable marketing option." (ETSI EN 300 175-7 Ch. A6)
Hi Adrian (and list):
On Wed, Jul 12, 2023 at 04:30:19PM +0300, Adrian Popa wrote:
Thank you for the help. I had started osmo-remsim-bankd with -i 0.0.0.0 thinking it would listen on all interfaces. I used a fixed IP and now the client can use it. This can be considered solved
I've removed potentially misleading references to 127.0.0.1 from the wiki page yesterday, and we also have the following patches in review which should make it easier to avoid (and if still used: spot) any setup that is using loopback addresses:
* https://gerrit.osmocom.org/c/osmo-remsim/+/33812 * https://gerrit.osmocom.org/c/osmo-remsim/+/33813
-
Adrian Popa -
Harald Welte -
Harald Welte