Hi Ciccio,
we are trying to bring up a Nokia AirScale GSM BTS in an isolated laboratory using OsmoBSC 1.15.0. [...] The BTS is configured for Nokia Packet Abis over IP.
I am the developer who added preliminary support to OsmoBSC (much more work is still needed) for Nokia Flexi Multiradio BTS with traditional E1 Abis. My Flexi MR BTS (ESMB system unit + choice of FXCB or FXFB radio module, for GSM850 or PCS1900 band) supports both traditional E1 Abis and Packet Abis over IP: I have FIQB transport module fitted into ESMB, which implements both E1 and Ethernet ports for Abis, with BTS software supporting both Abis types at the high level. As a further clarification, I work with these old Nokia BTS not merely for fun, but because I seek to deploy them in real production operation - see www.usa2g.org. Note that I said "production" operation, rather than "commercial": the company in question is a non-profit org, hence the network we seek to build, serving those human users who wish to use GSM/2G as their personal cellphone, cannot be called commercial. But we do seek the full quality level of a real production network, no worse than commercial ones, despite ours being non-profit and hence non-commercial. Back to Nokia's proprietary Packet Abis over IP, I am very pleased to see that you made more progress with it than I did! I do feel, however, that jumping directly from Flexi MR with E1 Abis (newest Nokia hw config that works today) to the much newer AirScale you are working with may be too big of a jump - too many variables changing at once. Instead I wonder if it might make sense to take a more incremental approach: first get Packet Abis (IP) working on Flexi MR, then on Multiradio 10 (I don't have MR10 hw at the moment, but I should have no problem justifying the purchase of an FSMF unit when we reach that point), and only then the bravest move on AirScale. What do you think? You offered remote access to your AirScale hw setup, and I can likewise provide remote access to the Flexi MR BTS in my lab, with both E1 and IP interfaces wired up and accessible. But let me ask you: can you get access to Nokia's official BSC, whatever it is called, and get a pcap of Nokia BTS connecting to their own official BSC via Packet Abis? My hunch is that we will need such a trace before we can get Packet Abis working with any of those BTS models - in the absence of such working example, we are just blindly stabbing in the dark. Also please treat this response from me as very preliminary: right now I am working in a different area and it will probably be several months before I can properly switch my attention to Nokia BTS details. But when I do eventually make that attention switch, I will keep you in mind, especially if I decide to take another stab at Packet Abis, as opposed to sticking with E1 and building an FPGA-based adapter that would make our E1 Abis interface more efficient than the sw-heavy approach currently adopted in Osmocom. M~