Best regards.
Jean-Samuel.
:-)
On Tue, Aug 7, 2012 at 7:27 PM, Andrey Sviyazov <andreysviyaz(a)gmail.com>wrote;wrote:
Hi Jean-Samuel.
1/ A few weeks ago, we discussed together about phase noise issues to be
able to pass the GSM spec. You explained
HMC830LP6GE has much better
performances than the ADF4350. I know the HMC830LP6GE is a bit more
expensive but, as discussed together before, I really believe this worth
the extra cost. This would allow us to pass the macro or at least micro BTS
specs without the need for designing another slectivity board. This would
save a lot of work. Moreover, we espcially need this preselectivity board
for a micro or even macro BTS. In this use case, I really believe price
difference (like 40 or 50 USD) will be very low, especially compared to all
other costs of a mid-long range micro/macro BTS installation. Unless you
really disagree, I would really suggest to use the best performance
components as we reasonably can.
First of all, Robin said that ADF4350 already supported by UHD therefore
it could save time to implement it for UmTRX.
2nd, I think that parameters differences isn't really as significant (few
dB) as price and soft changing time cost.
3rd, it isn't last design and I am sure that we will change it for more
functions, performances and for housing adaptations.
Also I'm planing to buy HP4352 to design and measure PLL's, so of course
I'll test HMC830 too, but now we just have to be sure that it will work
properly and without risks.
2/ In my deployment in Mayotte, I will also
deploy GSM 1800 band base
stations because most of the spectrum I have is in this frequency band. To
avoid making another PCB for GSM 1800, could you design the board to allow
to populate either GSM 900 or GSM 1800 filters and matching passives with
the same PCB copper ? A single PCB would be easier to test and to maintain.
Moreover, this would save some costs as we will be able to order lager PCB
volumes. This could make a quite significant saving. Please let me know
what you think about this.
As I mentioned before, there are band specific components with same
footprint.
So, there are no changes required in PCB design for 1800 band, only BOM.
For example, HMC485 instead of HMC483 and FAR-F6KA-1G7475 instead of
FAR-F5KA-897.
Best regards,
Andrey Sviyazov.
Anyway, thank you very much for this design. With UmTRX, this would
really make a cost effective and great performances base station. Thanks a
lot.
By the way, as I am abroad, I may take a bit more time than usual to
reply to your e-mails. I really appologize for this and I will do my best
to reply as soon as I can.
Best regards.
Jean-Samuel.
:-)
On Mon, Aug 6, 2012 at 5:07 PM, Andrey Sviyazov <andreysviyaz(a)gmail.com>wrote;wrote:
I've found first error:
Missed AC block required for Vref pin of ADF4350.
Also translated some components descriptions to English to avoid
misunderstanding of Russian.
All newest files here in zip.
Best regards,
Andrey Sviyazov.
2012/8/6 Andrey Sviyazov <andreysviyaz(a)gmail.com>
> Sorry.
> Zip file here :)
>
> Best regards,
> Andrey Sviyazov.
>
>
>
> 2012/8/6 Andrey Sviyazov <andreysviyaz(a)gmail.com>
>
>> Hi all.
>>
>> Here first release of preselector project, schema and BOM.
>> Any questions and suggestions welcomed.
>>
>> Best regards,
>> Andrey Sviyazov.
>>
>>
>