Printing Fi/Di values from simtrace host tool (PPS)

This is merely a historical archive of years 2008-2021, before the migration to mailman3.

A maintained and still updated list archive can be found at https://lists.osmocom.org/hyperkitty/list/simtrace@lists.osmocom.org/.

Peter Stuge peter at stuge.se
Sat Feb 18 19:18:33 UTC 2012


Myonium wrote:
> Thanks, Peter, please find below the first results from the “speed
> issue" analysis:

Good work.


> 1.) I contrasted the URB chunks received in “simtrace host” with
> the usbmon output. => There is a 100% match. No data is lost in the
> “simtrace host program”.

Ok.

> 2.) I increased and decreased the buffer size (rctx) of the
> firmware. => If there were bytes lost, than always between URB
> chunks. Decreasing the buffer size improved the situation a lot!
> Reducing the buffer size from 128B (default) to 32B almost
> eliminated the lost byte problem (1 of 5 failed). With a buffer
> size of 16B I never had a lost byte. 
> 
> => Conclusion: The send_rctx with a “large” buffer is so expensive,
> that we are loosing bytes while sending the chunk. It solved the
> problem for me, by setting the buffer to 16B. However any idea how
> we could lighten the send data process? Any other conclusions?

Your findings make sense.

I note that all data to be transmitted is copied byte for byte from
the rctx data buffer into the USB peripheral memory. I had expected
zero copy. During copying, interrupts are disabled.

Basically the USB "framework" would need to be rewritten specifically
for zero copy operation, if the hardware actually allows that.

Meanwhile, going down to 16 or even 8 bytes per packet is fine IMO.


//Peter




More information about the simtrace mailing list