This is merely a historical archive of years 2008-2021, before the migration to mailman3.
A maintained and still updated list archive can be found at https://lists.osmocom.org/hyperkitty/list/OpenBSC@lists.osmocom.org/.
Mychaela Falconia mychaela.falconia at gmail.comSandi Suhendro <djks74 at gmail.com> wrote: > Voice is working actually since back then, my fault is using only > C117/118 for test call all the time. > Now I just test using newer phone both Caller and Callee and voice is > work perfectly! > [...] > There is trace in wireshark when using old phone as C117/118, the BTS > always freeze and send Measurement Indication all the time when calling > is made and answered, but with newer phone, the Indication is normal. In your tests with C117/118 phones that produced failing results, were those phones running OsmocomBB or Motorola's original firmware? If Motorola phones running their original firmware (which presumably had passed official certification and type approval tests back in the day) don't work with Osmocom networks (be it LimeSDR or other Osmocom- compatible BTS hardware, SDR-based or otherwise) but "newer" (meaning more proprietary and more thoroughly locked down) phones do work, then it is a very grave problem from the perspective of Freedom, and needs to be taken very seriously. Sysmocom has two of my FreeCalypso development boards, only one of which has been calibrated with a CMU200 instrument and fc-rfcal-tools before leaving my shop - the other board did not receive calibration because Harald claimed it early in the bring-up process, before I had climbed the calibration learning curve and developed my calibration programs. Looking at the photo in issue #2704: https://osmocom.org/issues/2704 The board you've got set up there is the one that did get properly calibrated before being sold to Sysmocom. Like all boards from that batch, it was shipped with an official FreeCalypso firmware image in its flash - based on the date it was shipped, it was probably the 20170831 build. Do you still have that firmware image in the flash, or have you erased it? Where is the RF from that board connected to - does it go to a sysmoBTS unit? Would it be possible for someone from Sysmocom (or someone from the community who have been set up with remote access to that board) to test and see if the FCDEV3B can successfully connect to Osmocom network using the official FreeCalypso firmware on the board, driven via AT commands? If Sysmocom folks are philosophically against doing any tests with FreeCalypso firmware, would someone else in the community be more willing? I am hoping to have the next batch of my boards (which will also be at hardware revision V2) made in the next few months (more precisely, as soon as I can afford the ~3kUSD cost of the new PCB fab run for V2), and when I get those boards made, I plan on giving away a limited number of them on a subsidized basis, free of cost to the recipient. If anyone here is interested in pairing the source-enabled (source freely published for all to see and to tinker with) network side GSM implementation from Osmocom with the equally source-enabled mobile side implementation from FreeCalypso (which is much more robust and feature-complete than OsmocomBB), you may very well be eligible to receive a subsidized FCDEV3B V2 board when they become available. Warm regards, Mychaela Falconia, Mother of FreeCalypso P.S. Regarding Sysmocom's other FCDEV3B board which you got before it was calibrated, if you have a CMU200 instrument which is itself in good calibration standing, you can calibrate the board yourself. The needed software is here: https://bitbucket.org/falconian/fc-rfcal-tools Given your level of expertise with GSM RF, I trust that you should have absolutely no difficulty with figuring out how to use my calibration sw if you have the needed RF test equipment.